Misdiagnosis: Youth Are Sick with Disgust, Not Apathy on Health Care Reform
Over the past few years, youth activists have confronted annoying memes suggesting that Millennial activists were just another continuation of Generation X, apathetic about the political process, not appreciating any opportunities for civic engagement. The elections of 2004/2006/2008 have helped with that, providing some proof that youth activism today is present, just not the same brand as the Boomer media/commentators are used to seeing.
Well, it turns out that some of these Boomers are still having a difficult time understanding the nature of our activism. Harold Pollack, a social scientist from the University of Chicago (who should probably understand generational dynamics a little more than he lets on), writes a particularly annoying diatribe lamenting the lack of participation among young people in the health care debate. Pollack speculates why young people aren't involved, and surprise, surprise: he thinks it's because we don't care about the debate.
We can all offer some reasons why [youth don't get involved]: It's hard for 20-somethings to get excited about free colonoscopies or co-ops and the public plan option. Some of this stuff is mind-numbing in its complexity--particularly if you feel decades away from needing most of the medical care we are now discussing. Maybe my own move from HuffPo to tnr.com has soured the younger demographic. Maybe it's summer vacation.
Pollack apparently forgets that he's another kind of doctor, as he doles out prescriptions for youth to get more involved.
With all the shouting and recrimination, you may believe that there is nothing you can do. That's wrong. First, learn the facts. Go to nonpartisan websites that explain the similarities and differences among the different bills. Keep up with the New York Times or Washington Post every day, in print or on line. Follow experts such as Jonathan Cohn and Ezra Klein. The bills have complicated details, but the basic structure is simpler than people believe.
Then get involved.
Call or write your Representative or your Senator. Get some of your friends to do the same. You'd be surprised what a real impact this has.
Sit your butt down at a town hall or forum in your community. Be civil but unapologetic in standing up for progressive values. After you attend, write about your experience in a short and clear letter to your community newspaper.
Pollock's diagnosis, though, is inappropriate. He makes a diagnosis before more clearly evaluating the symptoms.
The acrimony is what is making us sick, sir. The "shouting and recrimination" is evaporating any kind of will or desire to participate in this discussion among youth. Why rehash run-down ideologies, debating 'til we're blue in the face, when it doesn't do anything?
Dr. Pollack expresses disappointment that nearly everyone he saw attending town hall forums on health care reform was over 50. Maybe that's because youth recognize that these "town hall forums" are a sham. Ironically, these days, those who seek to participate in these discussions actually set out to stifle discussion. Speaking from a civic-minded perspective, which is the way our generation tends to view things, we want to talk about topics and problems.
The reason young people are "strangely passive" to observers like Dr. Pollack is that they continue to view politics through their Baby Boomer generational lens, viewing every problem this country faces as an opportunity to exploit the political struggle to stage a debate judged on volume and tactics, not rationality. Today's young people aren't enamored with the debate because it's not legitimate.
And once more, so we're clear - the refusal to engage in the noise machine that makes up this debate does not equal apathy. We're not apathetic about this. We realize that 40 percent of those uninsured are between the ages of 19-29. We get it, trust me.
Dr. Pollack's only one in a long line of people his age who repeatedly try to castigate youth for not being involved. Perhaps they should re-evaluate whether their own involvement needs to be treated before addressing others'.
2008 Youth Vote in Context
The following charts and graphs are meant to contextualize the unique role that young voters played in the 2008 election, and their increasingly important role in a winning electoral coalition:
2008 Youth Electoral Map

2004 Youth Electoral Map

Youth Vote Partisan Advantage: 2000 - 2008

Youth Vote Historical Support: 1976 - 2008

Breaking News
Political Wire:
Aide Who Helped Romney Not Offered JobBrett O'Donnell, a Republican operative "who won plaudits for bolstering Mitt Romney's recent debate performances is not being retained by the frontrunner's campaign, an apparent victim of internal ...Think Progress:
Super Bowl Predictions Open ThreadThis feminist football fan will be hoping for a Patriots win, not least to honor the memory of Myra Kraft, who vetoed the team’s draft of a serial abuser of women, made her husband promise that ...The Plum Line:
Greg Sargent: Happy Hour Roundup* MSNBC’s Mark Murray does a demolition job on Mitt Romney’s (left for dead but now resurrected) claim that Obama made things “worse.” * The DNC rushes out a new Web video featuring ...Tech President:
Slovenian ambassador apologizes for signing ACTA, Poland halts ratificationpHelena Drnovsek Zorko, Slovenia's ambassador to Japan, is one of the EU representatives that signed ACTA a week ago./p pYesterday, though, the ambassador reconsidered her position and a ...Think Progress:
Correction: Susan G. Komen Foundation Says Pink Gun Is An Unsanctioned ‘Rogue Scheme’The Susan G. Komen Foundation announced it would no longer cut Planned Parenthood funding after intense public scrutiny, but the organization still needs a public image shakeup. So Komen’s next ...
Featured Video
Recent Blog Posts
-
Herman Cain gave his own response to the State of the Union at the National Press Club where he talked about how grateful he is with the endorsement from Stephen Colbert because he wants to keep the ...by: Sarah Burris | 0 comments
-
Just a few highlights of things that reference the Millennial Generation. Read the whole thing here "most daunting challenge can be the cost of college. At a time when Americans owe more in tuition ...by: Sarah Burris | 0 comments
-
A great new video that the Illinois Caucus on Adolescent Health youth activists created about how young people need accurate access to information about sex and health to protect ...by: Sarah Burris | 0 comments
-
On last night's Colbert Report columnist David Frum called for an economically inclusive, environmentally responsible and socially modern Republican party. He called out Tea Party activists saying ...by: Sarah Burris | 0 comments
-
If I knew how to navigate pulling FM for the day in solidarity I would... but instead all I can do is post a blog. SOPA's Scary Facts Stand up to support the internet, pledge your support, contact ...by: Sarah Burris | 0 comments
Blogroll
- Ablogistan
- Apophenia
- Bad Subjects
- Burnt Orange Report
- Campus Progress
- Campus Vote
- College Democrats
- Culture Blog
- The Daily Background
- The Daily Taylor
- Ezra Klein
- Everyday Citizen
- For Which It Stands
- Generation Next
- Got Democracy
- It’s Getting Hot in Here
- Kevin Bondelli
- Kid Oakland
- Kossacks Under 35
- Left in the West
- Liberal College Kid
- The Low Post
- Matt Ortega
- Michigan Liberal
- Michigan Youth Political Alliance
- Millennials Changing America
- Open Left
- Penn Progress
- Planting Liberally
- Policy Farm Team
- Political Teen Tidbits
- Prose Before Hos
- Pullman Progressive
- Pushback Network
- The Raw Story
- Rethinking Youth
- Rock the Vote
- Scoop 44
- Tapped
- Think Youth
- Young Democrats
- Young MO Politico
- Young People For
- Young Philly Politics
- Young-Politics
- Youth and Politics
- YouthinkLeft
- WireTap
- Wonkette
If you have a blog written by or for young progressives, and you would like to be listed, contact Mike.
Young Progressives
- 21st Century Dems
- Black Youth Vote
- The Bus Federation
- Campus Climate Challenge
- Campus Progress
- Campus Wellstone
- Center for Progressive Leadership
- College Democrats
- DNC Youth Council
- DMI Scholars
- Forward Montana
- Future 5000
- Generation Change
- Generational Alliance
- The League
- Kossacks Under 35
- Lose the Label
- Minnesota Youth Caucus
- New Era Colorado
- Oregon Bus Project
- Progressive U
- Roosevelt Institution
- Run For Office
- Students for a New American Politics
- Swing Semester
- USSA
- Washington Bus
- Young Democrats of America
- Young Elected Officials Network
- Young People For
- Young Voter PAC
Cultural Capitalizers
- All Ages Movement Project
- Billionaires for Bush
- Drinking Liberally
- Free Culture
- Head Count
- Hip Hop Summit Action Network
- Ironweed Films
- Justice Through Music
- Laughing Liberally
- Lokahi Outreach
- National Hip Hop Political Convention
- ONE Campaign
- Progressive Book Club
- Rock the Vote
- Screening Liberally
- Vera Project
- Youth Movement Records



















