Iran

Around the Tubes - October 11, 2007 (WTF Edition)

Here's the good the bad and the ugly (mostly ugly) from the last week:

  • Starting off with the good, check out this article about the youth vote in the Politico. Yeah, The Politico. Say what you want about their GOP talking point tendencies, they've got a better track record reporting on the youth vote than most papers.
  • Now some bad. Real Clear Politics picked up that terrible Adam Nagourney piece and piles on some more. Why is it that these jokers always make it all or nothing with the youth vote. We're supposed to save the day or stay at home playing X Box. WTF? Why can't we just be a normal, respected piece of the electorate like everyone else? Note to Blake Dvorak - this is the second time you've done this to the youth vote. Read this and how about getting the story right?
  • The ugly: one of our own, Texas Blue, also picked up the Nagourney story and piled on with more anti-youth vote rhetoric based on bad information. WTF?
  • Now for some good to lower your blood pressure: FaceBook will soon lift the ridiculous ban on messaging groups over 1000 and will integrate group activity into news feeds. That's good news for those using Facebook as an organizing tool.
  • Brace yourself. Radar makes us all a little dumber with this "look" at the candidates.
  • We'll end on a high note - did you read about the student protests in Iran?

Mainstream Media Coverage Misses the Point - Ahmadinejad at Columbia

By SARAH LEONARD

Sarah Leonard is a guest blogger for Future Majority. She is currently a student at Columbia University and a Fellow of the Roosevelt Institution at Columbia University.

The American media has propagated a tremendous falsehood with regard to President Ahmadinejad’s speech at Columbia University. The bottom line, with remarkably little variance across major news networks, has been that Columbia is being un-American by engaging in controversial free debate.

This is hardly shocking from conservative sources, such as FOX news. Bill O’Reilly has been reveling in this story for days now, since it combines his two favorite subjects for condemnation – the Ivy League and a Muslim with a podium. He won’t have to imagine a new liberal outrage for at least a few more days.

But the journalistic travesty committed by more mainstream networks, not usual shills for conservative politicians, has been chilling. The typical news segment follows this pattern: a reporter menacingly describes Ahmadinejad’s ethical and political crimes. The reporter then notes that this bad man will not be allowed to lay a wreath at Ground Zero. But, the voiceover adds, Columbia will be welcoming the Iranian President on Monday! Cut to head-shaking anchor.

The clear implication of each of these sorry excuses for reporting is that Columbia University is the only place un-American enough to host this man. He’s been rejected by the NYPD at Ground Zero, but welcomed by Lee Bollinger at Columbia. This reporting fails to address the real issue of debate and diplomatic engagement, instead regurgitating right-wing talking points in sanitized form.

The Future of the United States Begins Today

By NANCY HUEMER

Nancy Huemer is a guest blogger for Future Majority. She is a
currently a student at Barnard College and Media Director of the Roosevelt Institution at Columbia University.

Today, the youth of Columbia University and every other institution of higher learning in America will have the opportunity to forge a bond with the youth of Iran that could prove to be indispensable in future relations with Iran. President Ahmadinejad will be addressing students and other members of the campus community in an honest, challenged environment. University President Lee C. Bollinger’s choice to invite the Iranian executive to speak has generated countless debates, both on campus and off, and it is the right to even hold these discussions that those defending the decision are uplifting.

While Ahmadinejad has made some deeply disturbing statements, the right to free speech in our country should always prevail. Our first amendment right is one that is so often misused by those who attempt to silence only certain members of our society. It is one of the fundamental principles on which our country was founded; yet it is easy to forget that not all members of the world community have this same privilege. The students at Iranian universities will not ever have the opportunity to engage the president of their own country in the way that students at Columbia will on Monday. It is up to the Columbia community to use this chance to connect with the students of Iran.

The importance of this occasion is amplified by the current population make-up of Iran. Two-thirds of the population is under thirty, giving Iran an extremely young demographic. While the United States has been making an effort to deal with Iran in a diplomatic way recently, our tenuous relationship with the country in the past quarter century has been strained. The young population of Iran could be deeply affected by the discussion that will occur today and if the students at Columbia University can prove themselves able to contest President Ahmadinejad’s views in a constructive manner, it can open the door to the possibility for a less strained relationship in the future. The students at Columbia are some of the future leaders of America, and the large young population in Iran holds the future leaders of Iran. It is imperative that these groups are able to make a connection through this event.

Making a real attempt to open up the pathway to future progress is particularly pertinent in the Middle East. Our moral standing has been marred by our ruthless invasion of the region and there is only one way that we can have any chance for the recovery of our relationships with so many countries, including Iran. We absolutely must engage them in a civilized, diplomatic manner. It is closed minded and foolish to think that the only way to prevent countries like Iran, where our relationship with them is fragile, from becoming our enemies, is through force or threats. We can never hope to improve our desperately poor global standing if we are not willing to engage all countries and their leaders in constructive, thoughtful conversation.

Ahmadinejad is a dangerous radical man, but is a major world leader nonetheless. We must acknowledge this fact and make a more determined attempt to open up a real dialogue with Iran. At Columbia University today, students have a chance to begin this process by simply being willing to question Ahmadinejad in a diplomatic manner. This event is too significant to let pass by with out utilizing it to its full potential. I genuinely hope that the students at Columbia who have the opportunity to, can challenge Ahmadinejad in an intelligent way, and force him to respond to what we, the future leaders of the United States have to say.

Around the Tubes - 8/22/07

  • Embedding is disabled, but Obama is getting a shout-out from Common in his latest video. Watch it on YouTube, or read about it at the Students for Barack Obama Blog. It's not Mosh - it's more a cameo than a call to action - but it's pretty cool. And hey, it's Common. If you haven't seen it lately, Obama's been getting more love recently from the Hip Hop community. Since he graced this month's cover of Vibe (and sat for a Q&A), the traditional media is also starting to notice.
  • Brave New Films has a scary new piece illustrating the similarities between the run up to the Iraq War and the current debate on Iran that is happening in the media:

  • Speaking of the war, here's a video of Iraq Veterans Against the War speaking out at Yearly Kos:

  • On this issue of the troops vs. the pundits, check out this piece by Paul Reickhoff of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America over at Huffington Post (hat tip to Blue Heretic).
  • DNC Chair Howard Dean continues to give big props to young people as the future of the party. Apparently his remarks at Yearly Kos are becoming something of a stump speech. Now all he has to do is convince the neolithic state parties to undo the purse strings and offer their young constituents a well-resourced place at the table.
  • Finally, I don't normally shill products (and I'm not getting paid for this), but this seems like a handy tool for bloggers and activists alike. And ePolitics runs down some potential uses.
Syndicate content